Pizza restaurants

Pizza By Dominick

4.7 101 reviews Closed 1969 New Scotland Rd, Slingerlands, NY 12159, United States

Discover this place

Pizza By Dominick, nestled at 1969 New Scotland Rd in Slingerlands, NY, is a gem that has captured the hearts of locals. Celebrated for its friendly staff and inviting atmosphere, this mom-and-pop pizza shop delivers an exceptional dining experience backed by rave reviews. Customers like Brian Kowalski praise the superb thin-style pizza and the must-try chicken parmigiana sub. Chloe Hanna highlights the consistent quality of their takeout, stating the eggplant parm and jarred tomato sauce are weekly staples for her family.

The reviews reveal a cult following for their veggie pizza, particularly when enhanced with Dominick's famous meatballs, a favorite of Jackie Ginn. The crust, sauce, and toppings create a delightful balance that keeps patrons coming back. John Tesoriero reminisces about childhood flavors, finding solace in their thick Sicilian pie, while Benjamin Swart expresses satisfaction with his wings, noting the pleasant surprise after switching from another local pizzeria.

Overall, Pizza By Dominick stands out not just for its delectable offerings but also for its dedication to customer satisfaction. From the homemade sauces to the hearty subs, every dish reflects a commitment to flavor and quality that is hard to rival. Whether dining in or taking out, this restaurant delivers a slice of happiness with every order.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pizza By Dominick before visiting.

Reviews for Pizza By Dominick

4.7

101 reviews

100%

15%

Review highlights

Based on 101 reviews

Pizza By Dominick is widely praised for its authentic, handmade Italian-style pizzas and Italian specialties, such as eggplant parmigiana and chicken parmigiana subs. Customers consistently highlight the friendly, personable service and the reliability of timely, accurate orders. The restaurant’s thin-style and Sicilian pizzas receive frequent commendation for their well-balanced crusts, sauces, and toppings. Additionally, the homemade jarred tomato sauces are a standout product that many patrons purchase regularly. Overall, the brand is recognized as a beloved local gem, offering quality meal delivery and takeout options that satisfy a variety of tastes, with many reviewers expressing strong loyalty and intentions to return. Occasional comparisons show it as a dependable alternative to other regional pizza spots.

Brian Kowalski

Jul 10, 2025

Easily one of the best mom and pop shops in the area. Friendly staff and superb thin-style pizza. Their chicken parmigiana sub is a must try! By the way if you haven't tried a jar of their homemade sauce... what are you doing with your life!?

Chloe Hanna

Jun 07, 2025

The best pizza and eggplant parm in the area!! We get takeout from here every week. The owner and staff are super nice and hardworking. Our order is always correct and on time. What more could you ask for? As a bonus, they sell amazing jarred tomato sauce--so good I buy it by the case. Thank you, Dominick!

Jackie Ginn

May 28, 2025

Love love love Dominick’s pizza! Especially the veggie pizza-course we add Dom’ meatballs to it!! Crust sauce and toppings are the perfect balance!! Tried their homemade eggplant Parma for the first time- perfection! Will return again and again!!

Benjamin Swart

May 26, 2025

Pizza was real good. Wings were also good. I typically go to another pizza place in glenmont. They couldn’t fill my order until 2 hours from order placement. (Friday night) Went here instead, pleasantly surprised. Will certainly be coming back!

John Tesoriero

May 10, 2025

This is my new favorite pizza place. We had the large cheese and a Sicilian pie last night. They were so great. The Sicilian is just like I remember from when I was a kid. Nice and thick with the perfect blend of crispy bottom and gooey on the top.

Linda Losier

May 02, 2025

We just moved to Delmar, and I think we found our new favorite pizza! We ordered a large cheese pizza tonight, and it was amazing! The crust was just perfect, and the sauce was delicious, with a perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. We enjoyed this pizza so much, and on top of it, it was on special tonight! We will definitely order from Dominick's again!

Isabel Hunter

Apr 27, 2025

The owner was incredibly friendly and nice. I walked in at 5:30 on a busy Friday night. They clearly had many orders in progress. But still, he said it would only be about 25 mins for a large pizza. When I was cashing out I explained that it was my first time there, and had just happened to stop on my way home from thatcher park. The owner was so sweet and gave me a jar of his homemade sauce for free and told me I could find it in local grocery stores if I liked it. The pizza was incredible and I can’t wait to try the sauce! Thank you for your excellent service!!!

Bob Bremer

Apr 04, 2025

Best pizza in the area! There's a reason I'm here almost weekly. Staff is super nice. Takeout only, they accept orders over the phone.